Why is My Child Having a Problem Making Decisions?

Kids who have difficulty making decisions!

Recently, Parenting Posse member Charlotte made a post about her daughter and how, whenever she’s faced with a decision, she gets increasingly anxious and upset.

This was causing huge problems because it was creating this cycle where her daughter would delay delay delay until the opportunity was no longer available, and then she’d melt down because she missed it.

I know this is extremely common because it comes up frequently in ParentAbility but we’ve worked through it with various families multiple times with success, so let’s talk it through.

Why do little kids struggle with making decisions, even when it’s just between two things?

Charlotte had specified that they’d tried reducing the options to just this or that and she still couldn’t do it until the time to make the decision was up.

Making a decision requires us to be regulated and to use our executive skills.

One is kind of contingent on the other if you’re not calm, you can’t access your executive skills, and making a decision requires almost all of them.

Flexible Thinking

You have to be able to quickly think of all the different outcomes that these two options could result in, and if there are any other factors that might influence that. 


You have to be able to think about how each of those outcomes could impact you and the people around you.

You also have to be aware of how much time you have to make the decision which is a different aspect of self-monitoring.

Working Memory

You have to be able to remember your options and all of those outcomes. 

Planning and Prioritizing

You then have to take those potential outcomes and all the factors that might impact you and others, and prioritize them based on your values and concerns.


You have to be able to organize all this information and your thoughts in your head.

Task initiation

Making a decision and doing it. ANY ONE of those skills being weak could completely derail a child from being able to make a decision they feel confident in.

Ready to be a wizard with words during your kiddo's next tantrum tornado? Sign up for our 'Parenting Power Phrases' mini-course! This magic scroll of wisdom will equip you with the perfect phrases to tame those baffling behaviors from your toddler, preschooler, or kindergartener. Be prepared, be confident, and ace the next curveball your little one throws your way!

Charlotte had mentioned that often she’ll try to talk her daughter through the decision-making process and make suggestions but they’re always dismissed.

This brings us back to regulation.

When a child is dismissing suggestions from adults before even really considering them, it’s pretty obvious that they aren’t regulated.

A regulated child if they’re struggling with using a weak skill, will still give you feedback.

“Do you like sweet or sour better?”

“Sour, but what does that have to do with picking dinner?”

They can’t connect the information on their own- because their skills are weak.= but they aren’t dysregulated either.

A child who is dysregulated is just going to reject everything because the limbic system doesn’t have any reason.

If you’re trying to reason with your kid and you’re just getting stonewalled with “no, no, I don’t know, no I don’t want that either…”

You’ve got a dysregulated kiddo on your hands and you need to take the options off the table completely, go regulate them, and come back and try again.

There is absolutely nothing to be gained by trying to force a dysregulated child to make a decision other than more dysregulation…

This can become a vicious cycle.

Using weak skills causes dysregulation, also known as stress, also known as low energy.

Using skills requires energy.

Now you’re dysregulated, and you can’t access your skills to build them or use them.

This means the more you try to use them, the more dysregulated you get athis can go on and on and on.

It’s a cycle that most parents are stuck in with their kids, but very few are aware of it.

In ParentAbility, we stick a spoke in the wheel by first regulating a child.

Setting up that regulation cycle that is going to be a standard part of their day so that:

1. they learn to self-regulate and

2. they always have a refill of energy just around the corner.

Once we get them regulated, then we work on building up those skills using daily, fun, practice.

Most kids don’t get to use their skills unless it’s do or die.

There’s something on the line- people are watching them, they’re trying to meet an expectation and they can’t.

It’s not unusual for children to stall out when attempting to use their skills because now it’s associated with failure and stress.

By practicing them playfully in short increments every day where there’s no expectation, if you’re successful, awesome.

If you’re not, oh well, we’ll try again tomorrow.

We start to rewire the brain to have a positive association with those skills while making them stronger.

I quickly want to mention anxiety because I know I’m going to get questions about it.

Anxiety is a biological stressor.

Anxiety is our nervous system’s inability to regulate in a fabricated or anticipated scenario.

You’re thinking about what could happen, and your nervous system is reacting as though it IS happening to you right now.

There’s a spectrum.

Some anxiety is expected and normal.

We all experience it when unpredictable or new situations come up.

Chronic anxiety, also known as clinical anxiety, is at a whole other level.

It’s often co-morbid with other clinical diagnoses such as depression, and it’s biological.

Your nervous system can’t regulate because of a hormone imbalance.

You can’t externally regulate a child out of clinical anxiety it has to be addressed medically.

If you’ve been trying to regulate your anxious child externally and it’s not helping, it’s time to talk to your doctor.

If you’re ready to come join us in ParentAbility– awesome- I strongly suggest you check out my free class first so that you have a full picture of our process.

If you know you’ve got to figure out this regulation thing but you’re not totally ready to jump into ParentAbility, go check out the Regulation Cycle Workshop, it’ll walk you through the basics of setting up a regulation cycle.

If you decide that you’d like the higher support of ParentAbility after the fact you can apply the full cost of the workshop towards your first month of ParentAbility.

Share this Post:

Leave a Reply


Generic filters
Exact matches only

About Allana

Hi, I’m Allana. I teach parents of toddlers and preschoolers why their children are misbehaving and what to do about it without yelling, shaming, or using time-outs. When not teaching parents about behaviour you can generally find me chasing around my two boys, reading cheesy romance novels, or hanging out with my own parents.

How to Get Your Kids to Listen and End Tantrums Without Stickers, Counting to 3, or Losing your Shit

Recent Posts

Follow on Facebook

Ever been stuck like a deer in the headlights thinking “What exactly do I SAY in this situation?!” when your child is misbehaving?

Let me give you the words to turn it around with my free parenting scripts.

Uncommon Sense Parenting with Allana Robinson
Skip to content
%d bloggers like this: